Anesthesia is an essential procedure in medicine, allowing to ensure patient comfort and guarantee the safety of surgical and medical interventions. The choice of the type of anesthesia is based on several medical, physiological, and contextual criteria. In this article, we will examine in detail the main elements influencing this decision.

Introduction to types of anesthesia

Anesthesia can be classified into several categories, each tailored to specific situations:

• General anesthesia: total loss of consciousness induced by anesthetic agents administered intravenously or by inhalation.
• Locoregional anesthesia: numbing of a part of the body without affecting consciousness (epidural, spinal anesthesia, peripheral nerve block).
• Local anesthesia: numbing limited to a small area (e.g. dental work, sutures).
• Conscious sedation: Reduction of the state of consciousness to reduce anxiety and pain while maintaining a response to verbal stimulation.

Criteria related to the patient's health status

The choice of anesthesia type largely depends on the patient's medical history and physiological characteristics.

1. Age and general physical condition

• Elderly patients: Increased sensitivity to anesthetic agents, increased risk of cardiovascular and respiratory complications.
• Pediatric patients: Faster drug metabolism, increased sensitivity to high doses.
• General health status: Evaluated via the American Society of Anesthesiologists (ASA) scale, which classifies patients according to their overall health status.

2. Medical history

• Cardiovascular diseases (hypertension, heart failure): Increased risk of hemodynamic instability under general anesthesia.
• Respiratory pathologies (asthma, COPD): Increased risk of postoperative respiratory complications.
• Renal or hepatic insufficiency: Altered metabolism of anesthetics, requiring dose adjustment.
• Allergies to local or general anesthetics: Need to opt for secure alternatives.

3. Neurological and psychological status

• Epilepsy or neurological disorders: Increased risk of seizures under certain anesthetics.
• Psychiatric disorders: Some patients may react badly to general anesthesia, requiring lighter sedation.

Type of surgery

The choice of anesthesia depends on the type, duration, and invasiveness of the procedure.

1. Duration and complexity of the intervention

• Long and complex interventions: Favor general anesthesia to ensure optimal comfort (see this article on anesthesia for cardiac surgery).
• Outpatient and short-stay surgery: Prefer locoregional anesthesia or conscious sedation for rapid awakening and faster recovery.

2. Surgical site

• Abdominal or thoracic surgery: Often requiring general anesthesia.
• Orthopedic surgery of the limbs: Possibility of using a peripheral nerve block.
• Ophthalmological or ENT surgery: May be performed under sedation with local anesthesia.

Factors related to risks and benefits

The evaluation of risks and benefits is crucial in the final decision.

1. Risks associated with anesthesia

• General anesthesia: nausea, vomiting, short-term memory impairment, respiratory complications.
• Locoregional anesthesia: risk of hypotension, prolonged nerve block.
• Local anesthesia: allergic reactions, anesthesia failure requiring conversion to general anesthesia.

2. Recovery and side effects

• Rapid awakening and recovery thanks to locoregional anesthesia.
• Fewer post-operative pain with a good nerve block.

Patient preferences and comfort

• Patient anxiety: Some patients prefer to be completely unconscious during the procedure.
• Previous experience: A bad experience with one type of anesthesia can influence the choice.

Availability of resources and medical expertise

• Access to a qualified anesthesiologist is a determining factor.
• Some hospitals do not have specialized equipment or staff for certain types of anesthesia.

Conclusion

The choice of anesthesia type is based on a comprehensive assessment taking into account the patient's health status, the nature of the procedure, and the associated risks. A discussion between the patient, the anesthesiologist, and the surgeon is essential to choose the most appropriate option.

Ultimately, a personalized approach ensures both patient safety and optimal comfort.

‍